1. Parenting & Family

Exploring Genealogy 

with

Special Guest
Bill Hocutt aka Uncle Hiram
genealogy columnist for the Houston Gazette & Southern Footprints Magazine

 
"Rednecks, Rumors & Family Shame
What NOT to Include in Your Family History"

 

Transcript of Chat - 27 February, 2001

UnkHiram Hi My name is Uncle Hiram, I write the Adventures in Genealogy
UnkHiram Been doing the column for a couple of years now
UnkHiram I recently wrote a column on what to include and what NOT to include in your Genealogy
UnkHiram My main point was to use a lot of common sense
UnkHiram Dont include anything that will only hurt some one who reads it
UnkHiram For example
UnkHiram One of my cousins was murdered about two years ago,
UnkHiram I have all the documentation, newspaper reports etc
UnkHiram But All I included in his bio was that he was murdered and the date
UnkHiram I could not think of anything that would be gained from hurting his mother by including the grisly details
UnkHiram On the other hand, I have an ancestor in the 1880's that was convicted of rustling
UnkHiram I include every detail on him, because of the distance in time
UnkHiram He had become a "Character" instead of a person
UnkHiram Ok, let me fingers rest for a second, any questions yet?
beejay What about the family who doesn't want to hear "father unknown"?
genealogyADM I have a personal scenario
UnkHiram BJ, You mean a recent one?
beejay My grandmother in 1897, children still alive.
UnkHiram BJ< if so, my rule of thumb is to go by the birth certificate, what it says is what I use
UnkHiram BJ, is a matter of not finding the info yet or was the gentleman not known?
beejay That's where it gets strange - the birth certificate lists her mother by her married name but she got married 2 years later.
rikki .*peek*
Shatys HI rikki
UnkHiram BJ, that was sorta common back then, Folks got married when they moved in together
beejay And they got upset with me?
UnkHiram but the preacher might not be around for a year or two if they lived in the boonies
rikki Hiay Shatys....hope I didn't miss to much but I'll try to be quiet and listen for a bit :)
UnkHiram Hi Rikki, You didn't miss much, just me making jokes (GRIN)
genealogyADM LOL Rikki! - Welcome :)
beejay Didn't know that. So the parents may have been a "couple" but not married by the church?
UnkHiram BJ, that is one of the traps of genealogy, when you find something that folks dont like it will upset folks
UnkHiram BJ< exactly
beejay Family should be able to live with that.
rikki Hiya Unk and Kim......well....I'm not to good a behavin but I'll try for a bit at least...k? :)
genealogyADM I found a will for one of my family lines in which I discovered that my ggggrandfather essentially wrote one of his children out of the will by leaving him a dollar
UnkHiram BJ, yes they should, you can leave the marriage date fuzzy until all the children pass
UnkHiram But hold on to the Marriage Certificate
genealogyADM Of course that is the child from which I am descended ;-)
UnkHiram Rikki, LOL
genealogyADM I am creating a family history book for this family
UnkHiram Boss Lady, that happened a lot
genealogyADM And some people in the family want that will included
genealogyADM and others do not
UnkHiram The info should be far back enough that it won't upset folks, I mean after all it happened what
UnkHiram 100 years or more ago
genealogyADM I am reprinting most of the documents I have found in the book
genealogyADM About 85
genealogyADM He died in his 90's
UnkHiram Boss Lady, Is the son still alive?
Shatys Kim, If I left that kind of thing out of my book, I wouldn't have a book LOL
genealogyADM No, the son died soon after he did
genealogyADM I was planning to include it
genealogyADM I don't personally have any problem with it
UnkHiram Kim, I would use it, its a HARD Fact, Proven, Documented and very old
genealogyADM But some family members were upset with the idea
UnkHiram you gotta remember our ancestors were not all puritans
genealogyADM Mine sure weren't!
beejay Nor mine
genealogyADM I considered this to be minor
UnkHiram When It comes to dead folks, I usually add it unless it won't add to the family history
genealogyADM and couldn't figure out why some of the family members were so upset
JMae Well, the Puritans weren't all gray and sober all the time either!
JMae (or somber)
genealogyADM I guess there were a lot of hard feelings at the time
UnkHiram For example: My Great Grandfather has 17 legitimate kids
UnkHiram we have very strong circumstantial evidence he had 5 more illegitimate kids
UnkHiram I choose not to include that information because 1) I can prove it completely
UnkHiram 2) It would not serve to build the family history
UnkHiram 3) It would only hurt his descendants legitimate and illegitimate
rikki ho boy.....good thing ya'll don't know to much about my Martin side.....
UnkHiram rikki, LOL, someday I will sit down and trade "Black Sheep" Stories with you
beejay Seems my perception of how things were 100 years ago weren't exactly right
JMae There is a black sheep genealogy website, by the way ;)
beejay No way
UnkHiram OK, any other questions before I hit the next topic
UnkHiram Jmae, Yep I am a member of the organization
rikki My grandfather John....it wasn't possible for him to keep it in his pants cause with the number of families he has didn't allow him to *have* any pants. :)
Shatys Unk, Illegitimate or not, they would still be 1/2 brothers/sisters to the legitimate ones
UnkHiram Shatys, without a doubt, that is a fact, but I cant prove they were his and because of the part
UnkHiram of the country he lived in the issue of race is a major problem
JMae ooh boy!
UnkHiram One of them is now a Professor at a Southern College, I would not want to embarrass him
UnkHiram That is the Illegitimate branch not the legitimate branch
rikki Unk....do you know that it *would* embarrass him? I mean, does he know or suspect and does he care?
Shatys understand but if you had a situation where it could be proven and you didn't have the racial issue you would include it right?
UnkHiram rikki, actually yes, I have spoken with him extensively and shared info with him, he is a real nice guy
UnkHiram Shatys, IF I could prove it, I would probably include it, race issue or no race issue
rikki Ok...then that right there would be a dead issue then. That information would ( for me anyway) be held in trust and left in the documentation for future generations :)
UnkHiram rikki, Exactly what I have done, its in my research but I don't print it
UnkHiram OK, next point, Family Legends
rikki Cool...I got something right!!
rikki LOL
UnkHiram You can include family legends but you need to make sure you make it clear they are "Legends"
UnkHiram Unproven
UnkHiram For Example: My Grandmother lived in Cooper Texas in the 1920's, One of her Babysitters
UnkHiram was Bonnie of Bonnie and Clyde
UnkHiram That is a family legend, we don't have proof
UnkHiram I put it in her section with the Note that it was a Legend, unproven one way or the other
UnkHiram The time is right, but its impossible to document
UnkHiram The inclusion of Family legends will spice up your material, but remember if you cant prove it say so
UnkHiram Ok, any questions?
rikki hmmm........I got castles, inheritances, bigamy, and Gloria Swanson as well as Ed Maronaro...
rikki Or however you spell his name....sheesh.
UnkHiram rikki, LOL, unless you got documents make sure you say its UNPROVEN
UnkHiram but that does bring up a sore point
leslie How do you prove family legends?
UnkHiram Leslie, ok, first examine the legend
UnkHiram for example, say your family claimed that your Great Grandfather rode with Jesse James
UnkHiram First thing you need to determine is if it was possible
rikki LOL....Unk...no proof on the Castle....inheritance or Gloria.....but the bigamy and Ed are true and fully documented. :)
UnkHiram Was he alive at the right time, did he live in Missouri
UnkHiram If both of those prove out, then you hit the libraries
UnkHiram Looking thru old newspaper accounts of Jesse James Gang
UnkHiram Look for mentions of all the gang members
UnkHiram If he rode with Jesse, He will be mentioned in one of the stories probably
UnkHiram If that does not pan out, check out other material
UnkHiram See if you can place him in Missouri at the right time or if you can place him in another area
rikki Unk....I do have a question....it's in reference to those inheritance hoaxes of the 20's. Do you know anything about them?
UnkHiram Sometimes you have to Disprove something
UnkHiram rikki, I have heard about them, and I know Dear Myrtle wrote a very good column on them
UnkHiram a couple of years ago, but I am really not very familiar with the subject
rikki hmmmm.....I guess I'm gonna have to become an expert on those things..... :)
UnkHiram Rikki, on the subject of the bigamy and Ed, if you can prove them, and the bigamist is dead
UnkHiram I would include them
UnkHiram If he was alive I would hold back until he passed
rikki Ohh...yeah...... the bigamist is dead and I wish he were still alive so I could include it in all the publications.....
UnkHiram rikki, go to DearMyrtles site, she has a search engine so you can search all her old articles
UnkHiram Rikki, LOL< sounds like he ain't one of your favorite people
UnkHiram Ok, any more questions before we hit the next point?
rikki Unk....nope....He was my grandfather and he was the meanest nastiest person on the face of the earth.
rikki Ok....I'll stop now :) Sorry :) He just still riles my blood.....
UnkHiram Lets say you find and can prove that your Grandfather had a mistress and his oldest daughter was named after her
UnkHiram and you have the documents to prove it
UnkHiram Personally I would not include that kinda of information because it would only hurt
UnkHiram people
UnkHiram Your Grandfathers reputation, and your Aunt who was named after the mistress
UnkHiram It would not add to your family history, it would only serve to hurt the living
UnkHiram Provable but not something you want to add
UnkHiram Remember you want the facts, you want to document your family history
UnkHiram But more than likely your goal is not to damage the family
UnkHiram On the other hand, if you can prove he had a mistress and they had a child
UnkHiram and you talk with the child
rikki The other people are the only reason I won't include this information. Not because they don't all know already....the cops picked him up and his 3 wives and 2 girlfriends all got to meet one another then....but his other children and the rest of the family do want to be included....we just can't figure out how to everyone's satisfaction.
UnkHiram barring any other extenuating circumstances, add it
UnkHiram rikki, that calls for some tact and being a little fuzzy
UnkHiram I would include all the wives as alternate spouses, list the kids
UnkHiram Just don't put in the Marriage dates until all the wives and their kids are dead
UnkHiram But keep the material in your research
UnkHiram ok, any questions?
UnkHiram I mean besides where can you read the Adventures in Genealogy
UnkHiram (www.stategensites.com or www.houstongazette.com)
rikki I've tried that.....but there are arguments over who gets listed first...and who is his *real* children......Otherwise known as first children.....but I'll keep trying :) Thanks :)
UnkHiram (GRIN) free plug
UnkHiram rikki, I can help you there, First Married, First LIsted
Shatys Unk, As with most families, back a couple generations I have several cousins who married and nieces marrying uncles etc. would you point that out in your notes or just let the reader figure it out?
UnkHiram All the children are real, and should be listed
rikki LOL.....We have to go on time then...cause he married the first 2 on the same day....*sigh*
UnkHiram Shatys, you must have southern roots, I have the same problem
UnkHiram Shatys, I don't make a point of it, but I don't hide it either
Shatys It's just confusing to figure out who is who and the notes makes it easier
UnkHiram rikki, Are you sure we ain't related?
UnkHiram Shatys, You can put it in your notes, But at least with mine, I don't print that particular note
rikki Unk.....LOL....nope....We could be....I lived in Channelview for a bit. :)
Shatys Are you saying that was mostly a southern thing, I thought it was common everywhere
UnkHiram Shatys, have you made a descendant chart for your ancestors
genealogyADM I find it a lot more in my Southern ancestors than anywhere else
Shatys Unk, yes
UnkHiram Shatys, No it was not exclusively southern, But it seem to happen a lot more in the south
genealogyADM But I also think that may have something to do with the fact that those families just didn't move around as much
genealogyADM Farming families also seemed to have lots of children
UnkHiram Kim, exactly, and you gotta remember most of the cities were in the North
UnkHiram The pool to select from was smaller
genealogyADM And so the major population of a small southern town would come from a handful of families
Shatys I have one ancestor that married 4 sisters (as each one died) and then married a niece
genealogyADM LOL Sharon!
UnkHiram Shatys, here is what I have done, On my descendant chart I ran extra lines to show the cross polonization
UnkHiram Sharon, Was his name NEWKIRK by any chance?
rikki cross polonization......LOL....good one Unk.....ROFL
Shatys Unk, No MAXWELL
UnkHiram ok, thought i would take a shot (GRIN)
Shatys you got one too Unk?
UnkHiram Sharon, Yep, on a collateral line, Sam Newkirk, married all three of the daughters of Israel Hocutt
Shatys Nothing like keeping it in the family
UnkHiram LOL, yep
Shatys Purebred
UnkHiram The basic rule of thumb is when deciding what to add and what not to add
UnkHiram is use common sense
UnkHiram Will this UNPROVEN fact upset Grandma
UnkHiram If they are Proven facts, you have to use a little judgment and compassion
UnkHiram I am not suggesting hiding things
UnkHiram but I am suggesting not add material that will only hurt folks
UnkHiram But by all means, keep the info, document it and pass it on to the next generation of researchers
rikki Hiya stearman...welcome
stearman hi
stearman i'm new so i'm just going to listen if you don't mind
UnkHiram Any other questions? Kim did I ever answer yours?
rikki rikki offers some of her popcorn to stearman.......
genealogyADM Yes, you answered mine
genealogyADM :-)
UnkHiram Stearman, Thats fine, just sit back and relax, the popcorn is free
rikki . *munch* *munch*
rikki BECCA!!!!
rikki Hiya :)
genealogyADM I have a question about what to include or Not include about living relatives
BeccaRose hey Rikki
UnkHiram Fire away
Shatys Hi Becca
BeccaRose hi all y'all
genealogyADM There was a big debate going on in my forum over it a few weeks back
UnkHiram Hi Miss Becca
BeccaRose hello there
genealogyADM Hi Becca :)
UnkHiram oh I love controversial subjects LOL
BeccaRose sorry I'm late.....but go on and I'll catch up I'm sure
genealogyADM There is a gentleman who is producing a family history book and he is including info on other living relatives
genealogyADM and doesn't feel he should have to ask permission
UnkHiram Kim, My rule of thumb is simple, I will not include any info on folks under the age of 18 except who their parents were
genealogyADM He was able to obtain it through vital records (from states which were more lenient, I guess)
rikki Ohhhh.....I read that forum.....he was quite adamant about it too.
UnkHiram As for the Living relatives over 18, I ask permission, if they say NO, I don't include any info except their name
genealogyADM Yes, he is usually a good productive member in the forum
UnkHiram their spouses name and the kids
genealogyADM until this subject comes up
rikki He was borderline abusive about it.
genealogyADM Yes he was :(
BeccaRose I think I read that one too
UnkHiram He has the LEGAL right to include anything that is in public records BUT
rikki It was great reading though. :)
genealogyADM His view is that it is a matter of public record
BeccaRose yeah but there's an ethics thing if you ask me
UnkHiram you have a MORAL responsibility to ask for permission from living people
genealogyADM He said he wants his work to be a serious work of genealogy
Shatys A prime example of how to hurt the living---a friend of mine found out she was adopted by reading a cousins family history book
BeccaRose ouch
UnkHiram Kim, Serious means he has documents, proof of lines, it does not mean he includes pertinent data
genealogyADM and that it won't be if he leaves information out to appease someone's feelings
UnkHiram on living people
rikki Kim, you should tell him it might be serious...but it won't be respectable.
BeccaRose that's exactly what I wouldn't want to be guilty of
genealogyADM Exactly what I am talking about Sharon
genealogyADM Things like that shouldn't happen in my opinion
UnkHiram Lets be honest
UnkHiram it is the year 2001
UnkHiram If you include data about living folks
UnkHiram People can use it for less than good reasons
rikki And if people don't respect your work then are they going to ultimately take it seriously?
BeccaRose very well said Rikki
genealogyADM He has family members upset because he lists things like grandparents marriage dates and parent's birth dates
genealogyADM And even if those people are dead...;
genealogyADM the children who are still living don't want the world to know that their parent's were born out of wedlock
UnkHiram Kim, Personally, I would ask permission of folks
genealogyADM wedlock
genealogyADM He says he has thousands of descendants and won't be bothered
UnkHiram I send a letter out to everyone in my database alive, asking permission to print facts
genealogyADM I told him pretty much what you were saying and he jumped down my throat
UnkHiram If they object, I don't include dates
BeccaRose I think he'd be better off if he protected the info publicly and listed his sources.........more of a compromise
genealogyADM Just wanted to make sure I wasn't off base
BeccaRose shows he did the research and has the knowledge but also shows respect for the living
rikki Thank you Becca. :) I have been giving a thought to trying to learn to do genealogy professionally. And this guy made me realize how important it was to know the lines that can and can't be crossed.
UnkHiram Kim, you got it right, but sometimes folks don't wanna listen
BeccaRose you're not off base in my opinion
genealogyADM Thanks - just making sure
UnkHiram I Know I would strongly object to anyone listing my kids birth dates
genealogyADM It's hard when people ask for my "professional" opinion
rikki Kim, I thought you did a great job handling that guy.
genealogyADM sometimes I have a hard time sorting it out from my personal one
UnkHiram Of course I should point out I am not a Professional
UnkHiram I am just a redneck with a big mouth
UnkHiram (GRIN)
rikki Kim...and that's a sign of a PRO
genealogyADM LOL!
BeccaRose y'know he's probably more protective of his own CC# and SS# than he is of other people's LIVES.....very scary
Shatys LOL
BeccaRose lol
rikki Becca....he went over that point too...
UnkHiram As far as SS#, I don't ever under any circumstance include them
BeccaRose oh yeah?
UnkHiram I do keep them in my records, But there is NO reason to include them in a report
rikki It really is a very interesting thread....you should read it. I almost fired off my big mouth before I got to the end and I am glad I waited to read them all.
genealogyADM rikki - if you are interested in being a professional, then I would suggest you consider the "American Genealogy: A Basic Course" offered by mail through the National Genealogical Society
BeccaRose I know I started it but haven't finished it yet
genealogyADM I also have a section about becoming certified on my site
rikki Kim, I don't think I am ready to start at that level yet. I have a lot to learn first don't you think?
UnkHiram Kim, I will be honest, I am fairly new to your forum, so I have not gone back and read all the stuff yet
BeccaRose oh sure Kim.....give us MORE to find on your site......................lol
UnkHiram But I do gotta say I like your forum
genealogyADM LOL!
genealogyADM Thanks - it's fun
genealogyADM It's about more than just surnames and queries
UnkHiram Well Becca if you get bored on hers (Free Plug) you can try mine
genealogyADM We all have fun too
BeccaRose I'm haunting it enough as it is......there's not enough hours in the day to find all you have
UnkHiram www.stategensites.com
rikki Becca.....you ain't seen nothin yet.....I still have homework on her page that is going to take me a year to get though.....LOL
genealogyADM LOL BH!
genealogyADM Rikki - once you get through my class you will be ready to start that one from the NGS
BeccaRose lol....ok Unk thanks......not expecting to get bored but I'm an addict!
rikki Kim, that's what I figured I would do :)
UnkHiram Seriously, I would like y'all all to try SGS, there are six columnists on it, and unlike me some of them
Shatys Becca, (free plug for Unk) www.stategensites.com is a very good site also
BeccaRose very cool Rikki
UnkHiram actually know what they are talking about
rikki I have a question that is off topic but it's got me all screwed up on my genealogy search.
BeccaRose lol Unk.....I'm looking forward to it....I'm fluent in Redneck myself
genealogyADM BH - I love your columns
genealogyADM Very down to earth
UnkHiram Hinding face in shame, I tried to recruit Kim awhile back before I knew she ran this forum (GRIN)
Shatys and always leave you smiling
BeccaRose go for it Rikki
UnkHiram rikki, fire away if I can't help, I am sure kim can
BeccaRose I'll check it out for sure tonight'
rikki Ya'll prolly don't remember that I found my ggrandfather buried at a cemetery near me....his son (or so I thought) is buried there too....Harold bought all the plots and he has mother and father buried with him.
rikki I got a copy of that Harold's SS app yesterday....
UnkHiram Wrong Harold right?
rikki and his listed mother and father isn't who he is buried with.
BeccaRose rut roh
rikki Well...I don't know.
genealogyADM Give us all the details again
rikki he is listed as living in Madison County
UnkHiram Riki, FIRST are you sure you have the right SSN app?
rikki Unk....I think so.....but not positive obviously because of the descrepancy....but let me tell you what I do know.
UnkHiram Ok
rikki Harold bought 5 plots. He is listed as Harry on the tombstone...but the cemetery has him listed as Harold. His father Charles and his mother Ida...My 2 g grandparents are buried with him
genealogyADM How do you know they are his mother and father
genealogyADM in the cemetery?
rikki He was moved to this cemetery from somewhere else but he lived on Genesee St Lakeport
genealogyADM Do the tombstones indicate that?
rikki Cause the stones say mother and father...and they are Charles and Ida that are there.
genealogyADM Or the cemetery records for the plots he purchased?
rikki Lakeport is in Madison County.....
Shatys Are you sure Harry and Harold are one and the same?
UnkHiram Ok, Rikki, at first glance I would suggest you have the wrong SSN app, possible a cousin
rikki His SS app says he was living on Genesee St in Madison County
UnkHiram I would double check the SSN roles to see if there were two Harold INSERT SURNAME
rikki Sharon....according to the cemetery records...yes.
UnkHiram listed
genealogyADM Rikki - how do you know he lived on Genesee Street
rikki Unk...yes, there are two Harolds...but the other one was 5 yars old.
genealogyADM Just from the SS app?
genealogyADM Or also from somewhere else?
rikki Kim...no.
UnkHiram Then I would check the the census for that area and see if I could find another Harold or Harry
genealogyADM Do the dates match?
rikki Kim...from his obit and from a living cousin
rikki Yes, the dates match
rikki I'm soooo confussseeddd....LOL
Shatys just because Ida and Charles' headstones say mother and father doesn't mean Harold put it there
BeccaRose other than from the headstones saying "mother" and "father" do you have anything else saying these two are HIS mother and father?
rikki No...Harold didn't put it there...Harold died before Charles and Ida did.
BeccaRose lol.....gmta Shatys
Shatys LOL
genealogyADM What does the SS app say?
rikki Well....Why would there be a large PROSSER stone with all those names engraved on them if they didn't belong? And another Son and a daughter known to Charled and Ida paid for perpetual care of the plot.
BeccaRose I know that my grandparents bought plots for themselves and my mom and her brother....that was the intent.....but both my uncle and mom "gave up" their spots to other relatives who needed them so that could be something similar in your case
UnkHiram Rikki, Its possible they gave the spot to a relative that could not afford a plot of his own
genealogyADM Good point Becca
genealogyADM LOL!
BeccaRose lol....I'm gonna ne quiet now...lol
UnkHiram Becca, LOL, I expect you to write my column next week
BeccaRose LOL
rikki Well.....Harold bought all the plots.....and the records say he is buried there....
Shatys maybe he doesn't have a headstone
BeccaRose do you have the records from the cemetery on Charles and Ida?
rikki Yes
UnkHiram Well Folks, I hate to leave, BUT
rikki Unk....Thanks for coming..
UnkHiram I gotta read meters in Ft Worth tomorrow so
UnkHiram Adios and Keep Smiling
genealogyADM ROFLOL!!!
rikki I miss Texas
BeccaRose glad to meet you Unk....I'll check that site for sure
genealogyADM Thanks so much for coming :)
Shatys Thanks for the great info Unk
genealogyADM It was a fun chat
Shatys CLAP CLAP CLAP
genealogyADM I also made a transcript
UnkHiram I wanna thank y'all for a good chat, and for the invite
genealogyADM And will link to it in my next newsletter so that everyone can see what they missed
UnkHiram Anytime y'all want, I will be more than happy to come again
BeccaRose lol Rikki
UnkHiram of course I will drop by a lot in my civilian guise (GRIN)
............................UnkHiram left.............

 



About Ancestry - Free Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email

Discuss in my forum

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.